There are few acts in life more deceptively simple—and more culturally volatile—than making a cup of tea. It starts innocently enough. A mug, a bag, a kettle. But from the moment you decide whether to add milk before or after the hot water, you are declaring something profound about your character. Something your ancestors would have judged. Something the neighbours definitely still do. It is, in essence, a ritual masquerading as a refreshment. A personal creed disguised as a humble beverage. No one drinks tea by accident. You commit to tea.
I was first accused of being a “tea bastard” during a long weekend in Scarborough. My crime? Leaving the tea bag in while drinking. I’d never considered it a particularly radical act. It wasn’t like I’d stirred it with a finger or served it in a shoe. But apparently, in certain circles, a lingering bag is akin to inviting chaos to dinner and letting it drink straight from the milk bottle. It changes the dynamic entirely, apparently. Tea, I was informed, is not to be consumed with the bag still lurking at the bottom like a damp secret. The bag must be exorcised.
The Ritual of the Brew
Since then, I’ve become acutely aware of the silent social choreography that accompanies the making of tea. The way people glance at each other’s mugs. The pause after being handed a cuppa, when one inspects the colour, the strength, the… texture of it. You can ruin a friendship with the wrong shade of beige. And don’t even mention herbal tea in a Yorkshire household unless you want to be shunned for three generations.
Milk First and Other Crimes
Of course, the tea-making process is riddled with pitfalls far beyond the timing of the bag’s extraction. There is, for instance, the “milk first” heresy. Allegedly a technique born to protect fine china from thermal shock, it’s now more often deployed by those who enjoy provoking quiet disapproval at office kettles. You know the type. They also eat crisps during Zoom calls and consider five minutes of steeping “a suggestion, not a rule.” These are the same people who refer to their brew as a “beverage” and use the phrase “tea experience” unironically.
Then there’s the matter of stirring. Some do it as a gentle swirl, a calming meditative act like raking sand in a Zen garden. Others thrash the spoon about like they’re fending off a wasp. I once witnessed someone stir anti-clockwise and then reverse the direction mid-way through, as though trying to undo something terrible they’d done in a past life. They said it “helps the infusion.” I think it just helps people avoid sitting near them in meetings. There is no science to it, only superstition and a desperate need to feel in control of something in this chaotic world.
Biscuit Judgement and Mug Psychology
What we must acknowledge—painful though it may be—is that tea has become less a drink and more a personality test with liquid consequences. The kind of mug you use is a red flag all on its own. The oversized novelty one that says “But first, tea”? You peaked socially in 2013 and have strong opinions about stationery. The tiny, elegant porcelain cup? You don’t actually like tea, but you enjoy judging others who do. The clear glass mug? You’re a sociopath, or possibly European. There is no neutral ground here. Even a plain white mug says, “I gave up on joy in 2007 and never looked back.”
And then there are the mugs that never get washed. The ones with a brown patina inside that, if scraped, could reveal layers of your entire adult life. Each stain a memory. Each ring a regret. You may think you’re brewing tea, but the mug knows. The mug always knows.
Even the biscuit you pair with your brew tells a story. A Rich Tea means you live cautiously and probably own several beige jumpers. A Hobnob suggests inner resilience and a healthy disregard for dental work. If you dunk a Jaffa Cake, you’re either boldly redefining social convention—or you’ve never known true consequence. Custard Creams are the choice of the emotionally repressed; Bourbons, the chronically underestimated.
And then there’s the dunking technique itself. Do you go all-in? A confident plunge followed by immediate consumption? Or do you hover cautiously, calculating the sog-factor with military precision? A moment too long and your biscuit collapses like a failed investment. Too short and it’s just a warm disappointment. Either way, you’re left with crumbs in your drink and questions about your own decisiveness.
More Than Just a Drink
All of which leads us to the unspoken truth of the British tea experience: it is not about flavour. It is about ritual, and judgment, and passive-aggressively implying that someone else has made it wrong. It is an expression of deeply rooted cultural neuroses. A cup of tea is a performance, a statement, and a silent protest against modernity, all in one mildly steaming vessel.
We may pretend that tea is comforting, a national balm in liquid form. But deep down, every cup is a battlefield. The war isn’t between Yorkshire and PG Tips. It’s between us and the creeping suspicion that maybe, just maybe, we are the tea bastard. And worse—everyone knows it.
So the next time you make a cup, be mindful. Not of the temperature, or the steep time, or whether the milk has gone a bit funny. Be mindful of the eyes watching. Judging. Ranking you in the secret national database of acceptable tea practice. And if you leave your used tea bag in the sink, unwrapped and leaking tannin like a bleeding sachet of regret?
You deserve whatever hell you’re steeping in.
And remember this: in Britain, no one is more than two social missteps away from being offered tea as a form of subtle punishment. Never a hug. Never a word of comfort. Just a mug placed in front of you, full of scalding, judgmental beige.
Drink it. But know: the tea is watching you too.
Dwight Warner is the quintessential oddball Brit, with a weirdly American-sounding name, who has a knack for turning the mundane into the extraordinary. Hailing originally from London, now living in the sleepy depths of Lincolnshire but claiming an allegiance to the absurd, Dwight has perfected the art of finding the surreal in real life. Whether it’s a spirited rant about the philosophical implications of queueing or a deep dive into why tea tastes better in a mug older than you, his blogs blur the line between the abstract and the everyday.
With an irreverent wit and a penchant for tangents that somehow come full circle, Dwight Warner doesn’t just write; he performs on the page. His humour is both sharp and delightfully nonsensical, like Monty Python met your nosiest neighbour and they decided to co-write a diary.
Known for being gregarious, Dwight is the life of any (real or metaphorical) party, whether he’s deconstructing the existential crisis of mismatched socks or sharing his inexplicable theories about why pigeons are secretly running the economy.
A larger-than-life personality with a laugh as loud as his opinions, Dwight Warner invites readers to step into a world where everything’s slightly askew—and that’s exactly how he likes it.
Discover more from untypicable
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.