If you’ve ever looked into your dog’s eyes mid-crisis — say, while Googling “can you live off cereal for a month?” — and felt that familiar pang of canine disappointment, good news: you’re not paranoid. According to researchers at the University of Bristol, dogs are not only emotionally complex creatures, but they may be optimists or pessimists. Which means your dog isn’t just staring at you. It’s evaluating.
And not just evaluating — possibly writing up a full psychological profile.
The Science Bit (You Know, for Credibility)
In a recent study led by the University of Bristol, researchers worked with 66 medical detection dogs — the kind that can sniff out cancer, Parkinson’s disease, or that half-eaten sandwich you dropped behind the sofa in 2019. These four-legged professionals were tested to see if they had a “glass-half-full” attitude or were more of the “this-bowl-is-empty-and-so-is-life” persuasion.
Dogs were taught that a bowl placed in one location always had food, and in another, it never did. Then came the curveball: a bowl was placed somewhere ambiguous. The dogs who bounded over, tail wagging, ready to believe in the inherent goodness of bowl-based surprises, were deemed optimists. The ones who hesitated or approached with all the enthusiasm of a hungover student to a 9am lecture were classed as pessimists.
The results? The optimists were generally better at their sniffing jobs. They were more confident, more playful, and presumably more likely to put “team player” on their LinkedIn profiles. Meanwhile, the pessimists made fewer mistakes — cautious little analysts who may not trust the world, but whose attention to detail would make them exceptional proofreaders or very critical in pub quizzes.
So What Does This Mean for You?
It means your dog is judging your vibes, and possibly wondering why you don’t chase your dreams (or at least the postman) with more enthusiasm.
If your dog’s an optimist, it likely believes you’ll eventually finish that DIY project, call your grandmother back, or finally give up on your “mystery soup” diet plan. If it’s a pessimist, it’s already quietly assessing your survival odds in the next financial downturn and sketching up an emergency exit plan.
And just when you thought it couldn’t get any worse — the cat is taking minutes.
Enter: Cats. Plotting Since the Dawn of Time.
Now, cats weren’t part of the Bristol study (largely because cats don’t take kindly to being studied; they prefer to study you). But let’s not pretend they aren’t involved. Where dogs worry about whether you’re okay, cats sit silently atop high surfaces, mentally filing your every poor decision into a large, disdainful folder labelled “Typical Human Behaviour.”
If dogs are tiny therapists with tails, cats are aloof peer reviewers grading your life with a biro and a cutting remark. And when the great reckoning comes — when society collapses and all that remains are tinned beans, broken smartphones, and abandoned escalators — optimistic dogs will still be charging joyfully into the unknown. Pessimistic dogs will be rationing biscuits and running logistics. And cats? Cats will be quietly running everything, while we beg for a scrap of their approval.
Is My Dog an Optimist?
Good question. According to the researchers, there are a few signs you might have a sunny-side-up dog lounging on your sofa, judging you only mildly.
Optimistic dogs tend to be more confident when exploring new environments. They’re the ones who charge into unfamiliar parks as if they’ve personally been appointed Mayor of Grassland. They tackle new objects (like vacuum cleaners or confusing flat-pack furniture) with curiosity rather than fear. They expect good things — treats, belly rubs, slightly undercooked sausages — and are generally more playful and sociable.
On the flip side, a pessimistic dog might approach new things with caution. They might hesitate at doorways, study new toys as though they’re ticking bombs, and give every unfamiliar object a thorough background check. They’re not unhappy — they’re just not buying into the idea that the universe is a benevolent place without concrete evidence and a full risk assessment.
If your dog is on the gloomy side, it could signal stress or low mood, but it could just be their personality: cautious, discerning, perhaps the reincarnated soul of a very sceptical Victorian librarian.
The good news? Neither optimism nor pessimism is inherently better. Optimists tend to learn general lessons quickly — “one escalator was fine, therefore all escalators are fine.” Pessimists tend to need more situation-specific training but are less likely to make reckless mistakes. Essentially, the optimist dog will leap into a river after a stick; the pessimist will double-check the current, the weather report, and the stick’s authenticity before deciding whether it’s worth it.
Both are valid. Both are judging you.
Final Thoughts from the Unqualified Desk of Dog Psychology
As a dog lover I love research like this that sounds “out there” at first glance, but is potentially so useful. Science has officially confirmed what we all knew deep down: dogs have emotional outlooks, and they matter. Optimistic dogs are like motivational speakers with fur. Pessimistic dogs are cautious analysts who might just save us all one day by pointing out that the metaphorical biscuit tin is empty.
And cats? Cats don’t care if the biscuit tin is empty. They’re already selling you out for a warmer house down the road.
So next time you find yourself wondering if your dog thinks you’re doing okay in life, the answer is yes — or no — depending entirely on whether your dog bounds towards the future like an excitable toddler, or stares into it like a grizzled war veteran who’s seen too much.
Either way, you’re being judged. Probably better to offer treats.
And maybe just stop Googling “how long can you survive on cereal.” It’s not inspiring anyone.
AJ Wright is a quiet yet incisive voice navigating the surreal world of sociology, higher education, and modern life through the unique lens of a neurodivergent mind. A tech-savvy PhD student hailing from South Yorkshire but now stationed in the flatlands of Lincolnshire, AJ writes with an irreverence that strips back the layers of academia, social norms, and the absurdities of daily life to reveal the humour lurking beneath.
As an autistic thinker, AJ’s perspective offers readers a rare blend of precision, curiosity, and wit. From dissecting the unspoken rituals of academia—like the silent war over the office thermostat—to exploring the sociology of “neurotypical small talk” and the bizarre hierarchies of campus coffee queues, AJ turns the ordinary into something both profound and hilarious.
AJ’s unassuming nature belies the sharpness of their commentary, which dives deep into the intersections of neurodiversity, tech culture, and the often-overlooked quirks of human behaviour. Whether questioning why university bureaucracy feels designed by Kafka or crafting surreal parodies of academic peer reviews, AJ writes with a balance of quiet intensity and playful absurdity that keeps readers coming back for more.
For those seeking a blog that is equal parts insightful, irreverent, and refreshingly authentic, AJ Wright provides a unique perspective that celebrates neurodiversity while poking fun at the peculiarities of the world we live in.
Discover more from untypicable
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.